Wednesday, January 6, 2010

Some Quick Thoughts in a New Year (a Little Late)

I recently read somewhat that a doctor at a university in England came up with a formula that found January 24th to be the most depressing day of the year. It had something to do with its distance from the holidays, lousy weather, and the fact that most people's resolutions are beginning to fade right around now. I'm smart enough and old enough to not bother with resolutions, the weather here in L.A. is in fact lousy right now, and even though I don't find this time of year particularly depressing, I do regret that here we are a few weeks into a new year and I haven't gotten around to writing a post.

What can I say? Some people galvanize themselves at the very beginning of a new year, I take three or four weeks.

So, before I left to travel to Brazil for Christmas (my partner and I had an amazing time), I had some thoughts about the direction I might want this blog to take. I was talking to one of my assistants and found myself saying "you know, I'd like actors to let me know what questions THEY have for a casting director." I'm so on my own end of the process that I can lose track of what the concerns might be on the actor's end. While I was away, one of my friends in New York put the question to a young actor she knew, who I've brought in for a number of roles. The question he had for me was how did I feel about agents calling me up after auditions to get feedback on their clients? He wanted to know whether that was a hassle for me.

In a word, yes. While I'm sympathetic to actors wanting to improve their auditioning skills, you're going to KNOW how you did after you audition for me. Also, if I'm auditioning you, I expect you to come in, do a great job, leave. We're both in that room to get a job done, and hand-holding isn't a part of either one of our job descriptions. The issue isn't whether you're talented or not. That's a given if you're reading for me. It's whether you're right for a role, whether all the variables that go into a casting choice line up correctly. We work at top speed in my office, with all of us juggling several different things at once at any given time in our work day. It comes down to my really not having the time to pause and offer feedback to agents. That's not to say that if an agent needs to hear how a particularly young or new actor did, that I'm unwilling to take their call. (I've maintained all along that casting is a collaborative process.) It's just that the feedback issue is not at the top of my list of priorities.

In any event, it IS a new year, and every year brings with it its own challenges and surprises, accomplishments and defeats (plus a few additional pounds, right?). Speaking of surprises, it looks like I'm going to be casting a TV pilot next. I'll tell you all about it in my next post.

16 comments:

  1. So am I free to ask an (slightly dumb) question on here then? :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Go right ahead. Not sure there's such a thing as a (slightly dumb) question.

    ReplyDelete
  3. We'll call it an entry level question then :)
    Would I need an agent to audition for you? And would a local N.Z agency or U.S one be preferable? Thanks Joseph!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am in high school and started acting about 2 years ago. I have always wondered if a role ever goes to an actor that was found at an "open call" audition. The one for True Grit has been going on for a while and I think you held one for Little Fockers a while back. Did the kids that got those roles come from those open calls? Are open calls usually just a publicity thing for the movie or do the people that attend open calls actually have a chance in moving past being "seen" at that open call?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Also, how important is experience as opposed to talent?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Kaleigh, those are both great questions. To answer your first one, strictly speaking, you don't need an agent to read for me. But the chances of your knowing what roles I'm casting increase dramatically when you have an agent, as that's how most of the information gets disseminated about all the roles. Also, if you don't have an agent, it's assumed you're an entry-level actor as opposed to a working one, so chances are you'd only be thought of for the entry-level roles. Complicating things these days is the economy. There are fewer productions, fewer roles, and less work to go around in general, so experienced actors are now willing to take the one-line roles, squeezing out opportunities for the novice. As to your other question about whether to go with a N.Z. agent or one in the states, what matters most is that you find an agent who connects with you, believes in you, and is passionate about promoting you. Agents in other parts of the world know how to reach me. The main thing is that you have a solid relationship with an agent who works hard for you. I'll address your question about experience vs. talent soon. It's a fantastic question, and I want to give it some thought.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Now to the question about the open calls. First of all, open calls have very little to do with a movie's publicity. The movie hasn't been made yet, and it can be years before it's released. When I hold an open call, I'm doing due diligence, going full circle, genuinely looking for the most talented actors that exist for any given roles. My policy as a casting director is to look in every and all directions, high and low. So you should never pass up an opportunity to go to an open call. Even, as is often the case, the role goes to a more known or experienced actor, or the studio decides they want to head in a different direction, it's always good to get in front of me. I have a great memory, and I make it a point to remember talent. I've definitely called in actors for other projects that I remembered from past open calls. Your job is to come prepared to an open call, be on top of your game, and make an impression.

    ReplyDelete
  8. i am so glad i read your blog today as i have a question/thought- as a casting director your aim is to find the perfect actor for the job, so besides talent what else are you looking for?? I am sure you see hundreds of people for any one role, and i am sure most of them are talented and fit the brief, so what else will get them a call back or even better, the job?? Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  9. It's interesting that you asked about this right now. I've been thinking a lot about the question Kaleigh posed about talent vs. experience, and decided I'd like to dedicate a post to it. I just returned today from Washington D.C., where I was giving a seminar about talent, so when I get a chance to write a post, I'll address this issue at the same time. Thanks for reading.

    ReplyDelete
  10. super :) cant wait to read it

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Joseph,
    I have both an agent and a manager but when I find a project that I am passionate about I will submit "direct" if they failed putting me in front of the Casting Director. How do you feel about actors being proactive and what are tour thoughts regarding outside the box casting...
    P.S. I apologize for being so bold but did you get a chance to watch the audition scene for Athena? If not I could send you a link. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Ok, so not being a kiss ass or anything, I have to say you have the most valuable feedback I have ever come across. I'm sure you get thanks all the time but thanks again. You seem to make the time for actors even though you are probably so short of time! Looking forward to your post about talent vs experience. Also should you have any more of that precious time, I believe actors should always train to master their craft but wondering how much training is too much training? Basically, can you overtrain?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Joseph, thank you! It is a privilege being able to ask for your advice and opinion! I was looking up a reputable agency here, and they only represent actors with more than a years experience. Catch 22 situation?

    Im chuffed I inspired a blog, cant wait to read it! Thanks! :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Joseph,
    I was wondering if you are interested in an actor (who has read for you in the past) sending you clips of their work in films. In other words, do you take the time to view clips of an actor's work for future reference so that if they were not right for a particular role for one reason or another (experience vs. talent, etc...), you can see how that actor continues to develop his craft?
    Thank you in advance for considering my question!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hey everyone. I've realized that I just don't have the time to write personalized comments to individual questions. They turn into mini-blogs, and as we all know, I barely have time to publish posts as it is. I'm going to collate all the questions and answers here, address them in a post, and tell you how I'd like to figure out how to give you direct feedback on my web site going forward. Your questions are great, and bear with me as I figure the best way to manage my online presence.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Yup I was born on January 24th...I love being an Aquarius and being born in the winter but it can be depressing waking up to, January 24th the day with the highest suicide rate in the country :)

    ReplyDelete